Sunday, 19 March 2017

Mdina Ditch

Image by: Lucianne Calleja

Image by: Lucianne Calleja
For the research of the “Landscape Design” unit, I had to select and find about a local landscape design. I chose the Mdina Ditch project since it’s the closest one to my house and overall I like the project a lot. A while ago, when I used to have some spare time during the evenings, I used to go for a walk passing through the ditch enjoying the surroundings. At that point I never noticed or observed the space very well. But now doing the research for this task made observe certain things that normally are taken for granted by users.

To complete this task, I went to visit the ditch several times in order to take images and do some observations. I went there at different times of the day and the evening as to observe well how it’s being used by people.
Mdina Ditch - Before - Source Unkown

During the week in the evenings the ditch is mostly used by people who loves walking or jogging, during the day from morning to evening it is mostly used by tourists and during the weekend it is mostly used by families. During the night, the ditch is closed but could only be appreciated from above, from the Howard gardens.

About the Ditch
The Mdina ditch serves as a buffer zone from Rabat and Mdina, where the bastions start. It is an area where rain water used to be collected in reservoirs during the knights’ era.

Image by: Lucianne Calleja
Created by: Lucianne Calleja
Before the project was done, it was a completely abandoned area from the authorities. It used to serve as a parking area, sports pitch and filled with citrus trees. But around the 2012 they started to come up with ideas to make the space useful and aesthetically pleasing. The concept behind this project was to create a space to be enjoyed by families, so it had to be designed as a safe environment where people would relax and rest their minds while enjoying the beauty of the surroundings. They also wanted to implement an original idea and function when the ditch used to serve as to collect rain water into a reservoir at the Vilhena palace in Mdina. The new project was then finished in 2013.
In order to do this project most citrus trees were relocated in a more organized manner, following the chosen design idea. The trees were replaced following the linear paths created, making room for full visibility to the bastions which should be fully appreciated by visitors, as they are an important feature of Mdina which forms part of the Maltese history.  

The new design of the Mdina is very linear, parallel with the surrounding walls. Overall the area is very quiet as it is situated in a lower level of the surroundings. The surrounding walls and bastions serves to block the noise. On the opposite side of the bastions there is the well-known Howard garden which serves as a buffer zone from the noise of a busy street adjacent to it. The Ditch has various seating areas, situated where there are the most interesting features around.

Image by: Lucianne Calleja
Image by: Lucianne Calleja
During night time, the bastions are brightly lit by large flood-lights, which then the bright light on the bastions, reflects back on darker areas, creating a focal point of admiration on the bastions. The lighting bollards are placed along the paths to give a sense of direction which acts as a guide to pedestrians. Lamps are used for seating areas, which makes it adaptive for seating purposes. Both lighting bollards and lamps has symmetrical distribution. The overall lighting is bright white, however least popular areas have warm yellowish light, creating a sense of relaxation and a contrast from the rest of the space, showing the different zones within the space.


The ditch nowadays is still in good condition, but lacks maintenance especially of lighting. During evening hours the broken lighting fixtures create dark areas, which blocks the user from appreciating certain features of the place during that time of the day. 







References

  • Abela Mercieca, N. 2011. Mdina ditch to be turned into public garden. Times of Malta. [online] Available at: http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20110113/local/mdina-ditch-to-be-turned-into-public-garden.345072 [Accessed 9 March 2017].
  • Anon, 2012. €1.2 million Mdina ditch project includes testing of sustainable rainwater use. Malta Today. [online] Available at: http://www.maltatoday.com.mt/news/national/21108/1-2-million-mdina-ditch-project-includes-testing-of-sustainable-rainwater-use20120918#.WMro8jsrKUl [Accessed 11 March 2017].
  • Anon, 2013. Mdina ditch project completed. Times of Malta. [online] Available at: http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130306/local/mdina-ditch-project-completed.460362#.UYqA3WsYzLg.wordpress [Accessed 9 March 2017].
  • Anon, n.d, The Presence of Trees in Malta's Urban Areas. MEPA [online] Available at: https://www.mepa.org.mt/outlook33-article5 [Accessed 11 March 2017].
  • Attard Bros, 2013. Mdina ditch Hard Landscaping Malta Project [online] Available at: http://attardbros.com/mdina-ditch-hard-landscapingproject/ [Accessed 10 March 2017].
  • Chetcuti, K., 2012. ‘Battle’ scene at Mdina ditch [online] Available at: http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20120525/local/-Battle-sceneat-Mdina-ditch.421226 [Accessed 10 March 2017].
  • Malta Independent, 2012. Mdina Ditch To become fully accessible. [online] Available at: http://www.independent.com.mt/articles/2012-0510/news/mdina-ditch-to-become-fully-accessible-309867/ [Accessed 6 March 2017].







Sunday, 12 March 2017

Library Design - Case Study (Dissertation)

Arch Daily, 2013.
A case study that can relate to my intended dissertation is the Subterranean Tunnel Links Library, designed by JKMM Architects, which was initially designed by Alvar Aalto in 1965. The main building is known to be a “masterpiece of modern architecture and a highly valuable cultural environment”, therefore known for its uniqueness of its characteristics.  

The new project wanted to redesign the existing library in a contemporary style that attracts various age groups (Frearson, A. 2014). The new project design expanded the original area as to increase the area and incorporate additional reading rooms mainly to meet today’s needs (Frearson, A. 2014). The design was quite challenging especially to be able to create a balance between the old and the new building keeping the same characteristics design by Aalto (JKMM Architects, 2013).
One of the aims the new design proposed is to create a connection between the new and old part of the building by respecting the original characteristics (JKMM Architects, 2013).

Arch Daily, 2013.

Nowadays technology is rapidly changing and developing, and this project aims to provide adaptive technologies in relation to the library, aiming to draw attention of different individuals towards the library (JKMM Architects, 2013). Creating new roles to the new library by creating various zones within this library for various activities. The zones were sectioned in three which were distinguished by the different use of form, textures and materials from one zone to the other (JKMM Architects, 2013). One zone was created as a relaxing area where various activities related with the library can happen, then stairs leads users towards the shelving area were most of the books are held, also leading to a subterranean passage that leads to the older part of the building (JKMM Architects, 2013). A sculpture like elements was incorporate throughout most parts of the interior. From the interior beautiful panoramic view are achieved with no obstruction, creating a connection of the exterior into the interior (JKMM Architects, 2013).


Dezeen, 2014.
The whole building itself stands out and contrasts from the rest as its exterior has a darker material from the rest of the buildings at the surroundings. The materials used for the exterior were dark copper cladding, which forms a unique and eye-catching texture (JKMM Architects, 2013).

Arch Daily, 2013.

Having analysed this case study, I really think that this case study is interesting and I’m realising that we tend to overlook the need of libraries in Malta and do not invest in such buildings which can aim to enrich everyone’s knowledge. If something similar is done in Malta, I personally think that it would draws children’s and parents’ attention, and they’d invest more of their time in literacy. This case study shows an insight of what I would like my dissertation project to be based on, but of course having the research to determine the aims and objectives to design a local public library.

References

Frearson, A. 2014. Subterranean tunnel links Seinäjoki library by JKMM Architects with Aalto's 1965 building. Dezeen. [online] Available at: https://www.dezeen.com/2014/11/12/seinajoki-city-library-jkmm-architects-alvar-aalto-finland/ [Accessed 11 March 2017].


JKMM Architects, 2013. City Library in Seinäjoki / JKMM Architects. Arch daily. [online] Available at: http://www.archdaily.com/360049/city-library-in-seinajoki-jkmm-architects [Accessed 12 March 2017].

Saturday, 4 March 2017

Group Work

This semester for most of the units, we need to work in groups. Working in groups isn’t always easy and there are various advantages and disadvantages. Personally, I think that having four units that needs to be done in groups during one semester are a lot, because certain tasks get me confused at times as to understand and refresh my memory about with whom I’m working with what.

Groupworks acts as a learning journey, as one will understand how to work hand in hand with others, which I believe that in our area of study it will be useful in the future. This experience of working with others is helping me to let others show their opinions and ideas. We are also learning from each other different methods and understandings. Sometimes working alone, might lead you to think through one point of view. However, sometimes I prefer to work on my own as I feel that I have full control on all my work and don’t need to rely on someone else.

Through these experiences, I’m still learning to work in groups and that working in large group of people isn’t easy as it’s more difficult to have group meeting and to have full agreement by all members, thus leading to numerous arguments. Having arguments in a group is sometimes healthy, although it depends on the quality of the arguments. Sometimes arguments lead to unwanted negativity or misunderstandings, which may result in a bad outcome. Moreover, to have a healthy team of people, there needs to be people having different perspectives and having different people having different knowledge from every aspect of the topic.

Although working with close friends is more comfortable, it is good to work with new people as this prepare us to our future career where we need to meet new people and work with them, whether you like them or not.

Currently having gone through a difficult moment in my life recently, I felt that starting to work with other people started to get me nervous and anxious resulting in less concentration on work. Well, from my impression some people don’t seem to understand what my situation is and I don’t blame them or need them to feel sorry for me, none of that but sometimes some people do not respect that other people might be hurt in their personal life. Personally, I’m not one to feel offended very often, but at the moment I’m trying to recover from a heartbreak which needs some time to heal so that I can get back on my feet. Moreover, I’m still doing the best I could and I’m determined to get good grades and work well as a team member so that we all get good grades. Through this experience, I’m learning to stay calm and have patience.



Sunday, 26 February 2017

Preparing for the Dissertation Project

The dissertation project require a lot of work and in depth research to be done. This week we had a meeting about what we need to fill out so that we can start the dissertation next year. But a lot of preparations needs to be done before we actually conduct the dissertation.

At this stage I feel that I have a good idea now of what the dissertation project requires as we already had an assignment unit based on that. This unit was as an introduction to the dissertation and we had to find out a topic which interests us, but can be changed next year. As a requirement to this unit we had to find and read from different sources to formulate a bibliography list. Then the proposal form and its presentation and then the literature review and its presentation. These were only a requirement for this unit as to reach the given criteria, with the aim that we get knowledge about how to start the dissertation. Although we created our own title for the unit, everything can be changed or refined till next year. In my opinion this unit helped me more to understand certain requirements that are very important to the dissertation.

Moreover, I still feel uncertain about my chosen title as there might be room for improving the title as I think, it could be more specific to what I intend to research about. My topic will be related to interior design specifically on public libraries. I still need to develop realistic and better arguments about the title. Doing more research during next summer should help me be prepared to develop arguments. Furthermore, we need to fill the ‘Statement of Intent’ form again and although I already did one during the unit mentioned earlier, I don’t feel confident filling the real one, as I’m not certain if I’m doing it right and I’m still waiting for the marks and feedback of that unit, which I hope that I did well and if not, I’m hoping for a good feedback of what I did wrong so I could improve upon.



As mentioned earlier, the meeting we had this week, was to inform us that we need to fill a form about who I would prefer as my supervisor, based on their area of knowledge. I already have in mind who I will be listing in my preference list.

Sunday, 19 February 2017

Debates

During this week’s lecture, we had to debate about the controversial tunnel that is being proposed between Malta and Gozo. I was chosen with the in-favour group and another group were against. So, we started researching as a group from our devices to find the best arguments possible to attack the opponent and also to formulate good arguments to defend our side. In my opinion, it was a very interesting topic to debate on, and last week's topic, was on the flood relief project in Malta, which it wasn't a really interesting subject to have good arguments on.

These exercises (debates) have been happening for the last weeks to help us understand the real purpose of a debate. Debates for me are quite a difficult task to do and I think that such exercises during the lecture will help me out understand what and how to actually do debates and put us on the right track. My main difficulty is that I’m a very shy person and talking in front of a number of people with their full attention towards me gets me nervous and I usually feel very uncomfortable in such situations. I believe that having great arguments won’t do magic in debates, I think that having an outgoing and a confident personality is much important as to convince the opponent, which I feel that such thing might get against me in debates.

Something that I’m not that sure and still need to get used to is how a debate is build up. If I recall correctly firstly, the first round starts by a five-minute introduction, then the opponent another five. Then only one group gets a five-minute round to ask multiple questions to the other group. This round needs to be done by quick questions from one group and the opponent needs to just answer. Then the debate continues by five-minute each group one after the other, answering, defending and attacking the previous arguments being mentioned in the same debate. Things that needs to be avoided during debates are the tendency to interrupt each other and that we let our emotions talk rather than the real arguments themselves. 

Sunday, 12 February 2017

Are Libraries Being Overlooked Nowadays? (Dissertation)

It is a fact that libraries are losing popularity and they’re not being used as much. I did some research from the National Statistics Office of Malta’s website, where I found the real statistics of how much libraries in Malta are being used along the past years.

According to the National Statistics Office – Malta (NSO) in 2013 the number of book loans from public libraries in Malta were lower than the previous year by 9.5 % (Ellul, N., 2014). In 2014, loans were also lower by 17.3% from the previous year (Galea, J., 2016), however during the year of 2015 the number of book loans increased by 22.5% from the previous year (Caruana, E., 2015).  These statistics are accurate ones and one would notice that libraries are not being used as much from time to time. For instance, taking the number of book loans during the year 2015 which is a total of 777,804 compared with 2012 which had a total of 848,167 book loans (Galea, J., 2016) (Caruana, E., 2015) (Ellul, N., 2014). That is a considerable decreasing amount, which can be worrying towards the use of libraries in the future.

Not only in Malta, the use of library is decreasing but also in England, which is a worrying fact that needs to be taken care and action upon, before libraries are forever gone (Flood, A., 2014). Another issue is that very few people are choosing the role as a librarian (Flood, A., 2014). 

One of the reasons that libraries are being overlooked is because of the new technologies, which are somehow taking over. Technology such as eBooks are sometimes being preferred over books as they have some advantages over the use of a book (Abram, S., 2010). EBooks can be very useful to people who are visually impaired as they have the option to let the device read aloud the text for them (Abram, S., 2010). This provides an easy opportunity towards such users, who are usually in the minority. EBooks has multiple other advantages such as, having the option to change the font size or type easily, dictionary function, etc. (Abram, S., 2010). Moreover, it can hold thousands of books in just one device, which allows the user to easily browse their preferred book in just few clicks (Abram, S., 2010). On the other hand, printed books will provide a user experience, by its smell and feel which enhance the user’s memory according to the article ‘P-Books vs. Ebooks: Are There Education Issues?’ by Abram, Stephen. While printed books can be long lasting and can be borrowed, although risks passing germs from one person to the other (Abram, S., 2010).

References:

  • Abram, S., 2010. 'P-Books vs. Ebooks: Are There Education Issues?', Multimedia & Internet@Schools, 17, 6, pp. 13-16, Academic Search Complete, EBSCOhost, viewed 11 February 2017.
  • Caruana, E., 2015. Statistics on Libraries: 2014. NEWS RELEASE. National Statistics Office – Malta. [pdf] Available at: https://nso.gov.mt/en/News_Releases/View_by_Unit/Unit_C1/Living_Conditions_and_Cultu re_Statistics/Documents/2015/News2015_117.pdf [Accessed 11 February 2017]. 
  • Ellul, N., 2014. Statistics on Libraries: 2013. NEWS RELEASE. National Statistics Office – Malta. [pdf] Available at: https://nso.gov.mt/en/News_Releases/Archived_News_Releases/Documents/2014/News20 14_118.pdf [Accessed 11 February 2017].
  • Flood, A., 2014. Library usage falls significantly as services shrink. The Guardian. [online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/dec/10/library-usage-fallsdramatically-services-visits-down-40m [Accessed 11 February 2017].
  • Galea, J., 2016. Statistics on Libraries: 2015. NEWS RELEASE. National Statistics Office – Malta. [pdf] Available at: https://nso.gov.mt/en/News_Releases/View_by_Unit/Unit_C1/Living_Conditions_and_Cultu re_Statistics/Documents/2016/News2016_140.pdf [Accessed 11 February 2017].


Sunday, 5 February 2017

The Importance of Reading Education in Relation to the Library. (Dissertation)

This blog is going to discuss few arguments related with my dissertation title which is, "Discovering Innovative Ways to Design a Local Public Library".

A research article named ‘Sharing resources - how library networks can help reach education goals’ written by Ruth Makotsi, argues about reading education within southern countries such as in Africa where people are very poor. It argues that in order to have well literate and educated people, it is to the utmost importance that they read, but to read they actually need reading materials (Makorsi, R., 2005). Reading is a very powerful tool to be invested in people to help them get knowledgeable, “broaden horizons and think independently and critically” (Makorsi, R., 2005). Promoting literacy is very essential to such countries, at the same time it is also important to other countries. Libraries could be a great way to promoting reading by providing updated reading material regularly. This article emphasizes on the impact of reading culture in southern countries, how it would improve their expansion in education therefore this would result in a better economy. “Libraries can provide information about all sorts of issues which can help alleviate poverty, and act as a focal point for the community” (Makorsi, R., 2005).

The article ‘The Role of Libraries in the Creation of Literate Environments’ by Lisa Krolak has similar arguments to the previous article mentioned ‘Sharing resources - how library networks can help reach education goals’. It is very important that environments such as libraries are well maintained, as this might encourage people to continue flourish their literacy skills by going to libraries more often (Krolak, L., 2005). On the other hand ‘The Role of Libraries in the Creation of Literate Environments’ argues that in order to have basic interest amongst people, basic education needs to start at home as parents should also be educated enough to encourage their children to read and make use of available reading material (Krolak, L., 2005).  According to the same article mentioned in this paragraph, children who are brought up in literate environments are more to succeed rather than those who are not. Schools are mostly beneficial to promote reading to children. It also argues that on the other hand, children today might get easily distracted by having more than enough easy access to technology such as televisions, computers, etc. which these eventually acts against reading education. Such technologies are also providing enough fun to children and they are distracted from reading for fun (Krolak, L., 2005). It also argues that libraries worldwide are not well funded and has low budget allocated to libraries individually. Due to this, libraries can be effected negatively 4 towards its service and in its provided materials including books, furniture, computers, DVD/Cds, etc. which are most to require funds (Krolak, L., 2005).  These things are important to be kept in safe and dry place, where there’s no excessive humidity (Krolak, L., 2005). It’s also important the place is safe from theft by having installed the necessary equipment/tools to act against theft (Krolak, L., 2005). 


In contrast to the previous articles mentioned, where they mention the importance of the library towards society, the article ‘Architectural Design Education: Designing a Library, Public Communication and Information Center in the Manufacturing Zone of Central Eskisehir Turkey, a Case Study’, argues that libraries aren’t important anymore and that “it is a fact that their [libraries] golden age has past due to contemporary reproduction and copying possibilities”, and that the internet is taking over the main role of the library (Caglar, N., Uludag, Z., 2006). Libraries are just places where people just sit and read together in public, according to this article. It adds that “libraries will survive for the sake of the attractiveness of the ritual of reading together in public that it serves.” (Caglar, N., Uludag, Z., 2006). 

References:

Caglar, N., Uludag, Z., 2006. Architectural Design Education: Designing a Library, Public Communication and Information Center in the Manufacturing Zone of Central Eskis ,ehir Turkey, a Case Study. International Journal of Art & Design Education, 25: 231–240. https://goo.gl/AzgWGD [Accessed 04 February 2017].

Krolak, L., 2005. The Role of Libraries in the Creation of Literate Environments. [pdf] United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization. Available at: http://www.ifla.org/files/assets/literacy-and-reading/publications/role-of-libraries-increation-of-literate-environments.pdf [Accessed 04 February  2017].

Makorsi, R., 2005. Sharing resources - how library networks can help reach education goals. [pdf] Book Aid International. Available at: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/c5ad/3692f8bfc620b24a54a3c25b5e56a6898b41.pdf [Accessed 04 February 2017].